A major report by former Labour minister Alan Milburn is published in full today, 17 November 2026, recommending that employer National Insurance on under-25 workers be gradually lowered to help tackle youth unemployment, the BBC reported on 16 November. Nearly one million 16 to 24-year-olds in the UK are not in employment, education or training, and Milburn's report proposes starting the reduction with retail and hospitality employers, which the BBC says provide almost 40% of jobs held by that age group. The recommendation is still just that, a recommendation, and most of what it is asking for already exists, right now, for one category of under-25 hire: apprentices. A chunk of this debate is not about future policy at all. It is about whether small employers are already using the relief that is sitting in the rules today.
What the report recommends
Milburn's report has been a year in the making and is published in full today. He has already set out its central recommendation: a gradual reduction in employer National Insurance for under-25 workers, starting with retail and hospitality, rather than an immediate cut across every sector and age band. The Resolution Foundation, a left-leaning think tank, estimates that scrapping employer NI outright for 21 to 24-year-olds would cost £5.1bn a year, and Milburn has said directly that an immediate, across-the-board cut is not the best use of several billion pounds of public money. The report lands alongside one already-confirmed government step: Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said on 16 November that the subsidised jobs guarantee scheme for 18 to 24-year-olds on Universal Credit will extend to people who have been on benefits for 12 months, down from 18, which the government says will help more than 90,000 young people into work by March 2029. The BBC also reported a real account of the problem Milburn is responding to: Collette Osborne, who owns two hair salons in Nottingham, said it costs around £60,000 to train an apprentice before they can work on a client unsupervised, and her workforce has more than halved to 21 staff since she stopped taking on new apprentices because, in her words, she feels "suffocated by employment costs."
What employer National Insurance already costs for under-25 hires
Separately from anything in today's report, the National Insurance rules already treat under-25 hires very differently depending on how they are employed, and have done since last year's Autumn Budget took effect in April 2025. Employers pay no National Insurance at all on an apprentice under 25, under NI category letter H, or on an employee under 21, under category letter M, on earnings up to the Upper Secondary Threshold of £50,270 a year. Every other employee aged 21 to 24, employed under the standard category letter A, costs the employer 15% National Insurance on earnings above a £5,000 threshold, a rate raised from 13.8% and a threshold lowered from £9,100 by the then-Chancellor Rachel Reeves at that same Budget. In other words, the exact kind of relief Milburn's report is asking the government to extend to all under-25 hires already applies in full to apprentices and under-21s. The gap his report is addressing sits between that group and everyone else aged 21 to 24 in a non-apprentice role.
Worked example: a ten-chair hair and beauty salon
Take an illustrative hair and beauty salon taking on a 23-year-old stylist on a salary of £21,000 a year. Employed as a standard member of staff under category A, the employer's National Insurance bill on that one hire is 15% of the amount above the £5,000 threshold: 15% of £16,000, or £2,400 a year. Employed instead as a recognised apprentice under category H, which is available to any apprentice under 25 regardless of their exact age, the employer National Insurance bill on the same £21,000 salary is £0, because the whole amount sits under the £50,270 threshold where apprentices pay nothing at all. That is a saving of £2,400 a year on one hire, available under the rules as they stand today, with nothing to wait for from Milburn's report. Scale that across three young apprentices and the saving is £7,200 a year, before counting anything else an apprenticeship levy fund or training provider might cover. It will not offset the kind of training cost Collette Osborne described to the BBC, a salon's real cost of bringing an apprentice up to client-ready standard is a people-management cost, not a payroll one, but the National Insurance saving is real, immediate and already available.
What it means for a UK business owner in practice
If you already employ anyone under 21 or anyone training as an apprentice, the first thing to establish is whether your payroll software has them on the correct category letter. A new starter is defaulted to category A by most systems unless someone actively changes it, which means an apprentice or under-21 hire can sit on the standard rate for months before anyone notices the employer is paying NI that was never due. If you are weighing up hiring a 21 to 24-year-old into a role where training from scratch is realistic, such as hairdressing, hospitality or retail, the £2,400-a-year saving in the worked example above is a real input to that decision now, independent of whether Milburn's wider recommendation for every under-25 hire is ever adopted. If you are hoping the report leads to a lower NI rate for every under-25 worker, not just apprentices, Milburn's own comments on cost mean that specific change is not close, and the Resolution Foundation's £5.1bn figure applies only to an immediate, blanket version of it that he has already ruled out.
What to do this week
Open your payroll software this week and check the National Insurance category letter against every employee aged 16 to 24 on your payroll. Confirm that a genuine apprentice is coded H and that anyone under 21 is coded M, not sitting on the default category A. If you are planning to recruit into a role where an apprenticeship is realistic, work out the National Insurance saving using the method in the worked example above before you advertise the vacancy as a standard hire, since it changes the real cost of the role. Our payroll service checks every employee's National Insurance category as part of each run, so a birthday, a qualification date or an onboarding mistake does not sit uncorrected for months.
What is still uncertain
Milburn's report is published in full today, so the precise detail of how a phased reduction for non-apprentice under-25 hires would work, by how much, from when, and through which mechanism, is not yet public. The government has not committed to adopting any part of the report's core recommendation, and has confirmed only the separate, already-announced extension to the Universal Credit jobs guarantee scheme. The Resolution Foundation's £5.1bn cost estimate applies to an immediate, across-the-board cut that Milburn says is not the plan, so the real cost of whatever gradual version he is actually proposing has not yet been published and will need the full report to assess.
